The Non-Obvious Insights Blog. Non-Obvious Insights
The Non-Obvious Insights Blog.

Dedicated To Helping Readers
Be More Interesting
Since 2004.

As Featured In:

How To Reward Customers Unfairly (And Get Away with It)

IMB_carrothangingIt is natural to worry about being fair.  When you have current customers and are trying to create promotions to lure in new customers, the last thing you want is for those people or organizations that you already work with or other groups of potential new customers to feel unappreciated or marginalized.  At the same time, you want to be able to offer the best incentives at any particular time that work for your business and not have to limit yourself.  So how can you get around this problem and choose to be a bit unfair … but still get away with it?

There are three basic models for unfairly rewarding customers that are being increasingly used by small business owners to face this challenge.  Here is a description of all three and how you might use each one to promote your small business.   

Tactic #1: The First Mover Reward

With this tactic you are setting up a promotion that will reward those who act quickly to get a specific type of service.  While existing customers might be able to take advantage of this, you can increase your chances of reaching primarily newer customers by choosing specifically where you will offer this type of promotion. If your business is focused on helping people to organize their garages and outdoor living, for example, you might consider offering a promotion specifically at an event like a Home & Garden show that mostly newer consumers who you have not worked with before would be likely to attend.  Then you can reward those who do sign up from that event and maintain your regular prices for the rest of your customers.

Tactic #2: The Random Reward

This tactic is self explanatory, but has the added power of engaging customers and potential customers with an uncertain outcome. Everyone loves to win something, but regardless of who wins the reward, you still have a chance to engage each participant with the opportunity to win. This could be something as simple as discounts for products, or more complex like a competition online to be randomly rewarded with some type of prize.

Tactic #3 – The Merit-Based Reward

More and more co-creation style competitions are being launched online where people need to share their best ideas in order to win some type of support or recognition. Doritos let consumers create Super Bowl ads to run on air, but unless you’ve got a few million dollars lying around you probably won’t be recreating that effort.  You might, though, be able to engage your customers and potential customers in an effort to share their best ideas on a specific topic that has some relation to your small business.  That could mean creating a question on and asking consumers to answer it. Or creating a series of polls that customers need to answer in order to “earn” some type of discount or special offer. Once you have set some rules in place for getting this special offer through actions, you can follow through and only reward those who are the most engaged.

This post is republished from the original article I wrote for the American Express Open Forum website. It is part of "Small Business Friday" on this blog (though sometimes I'm a day late!) – a featured series on ideas and marketing techniques for small businesses.

To read more articles like this, visit the "Small Business Friday" category on this blog.

3 thoughts on “How To Reward Customers Unfairly (And Get Away with It)”

  1. It’s interesting to put them into three categories like this and it makes sense. I’ve introduced all three types of rewards to varying success.

    Although, you do have to be careful. If you start to do it too frequently, people come to expect rewards. I ran a community where people heard about prize rewards, told their friends, and I was inundated with people who just wanted free stuff.

    I think you need a balance, and that’s what you’re suggesting here. Good post. Thanks for sharing.

    Buddy Scalera


Leave a Comment

The Non-Obvious Insights Newsletter. Non-Obvious Insights
Layer 97
The Non-Obvious Insights Newsletter
Layer 118

Skip the obvious and anticipate the future with our weekly newsletter. Join over 25,000 subscribers and start receiving the stories (and insights) you’ve been missing.

Newsletter Subscribe

All Books

#1 WSJ & USA Today Bestselling Author

Rohit is the author of 9 books on trends, the future of business, building a more human brand with storytelling and how to create a more diverse and inclusive world.


Have a Question or Inquiry?

Just fill out this form, and we’ll get back to you within 24 hours!


About You

What Are You Contacting Us About*:

Your Message